Jack Fry's has enjoyed local and national prestige over the years, establishing itself as a staple in Louisville's culinary scene. They have been recognized by several publications including The New York Times, Bon Appetit, and Southern Living. Most notably, Jack Fry's has been honored by Louisville Magazine with "Best of Louisville" awards for over 25 years, winning in multiple categories including "Best Restaurant Service," "Favorite Restaurant," and "Best Fine Dining."